<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<rss version="2.0" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:wfw="http://wellformedweb.org/CommentAPI/" xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" >

<channel><title><![CDATA[Wisconsin Justice Initiative Inc. - Blog]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.wjiinc.org/blog]]></link><description><![CDATA[Blog]]></description><pubDate>Thu, 12 Nov 2026 11:38:16 -0600</pubDate><generator>Weebly</generator><item><title><![CDATA[Wisconsin Court of Appeals allows 911 dispatch as reverse caller ID for police]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/wisconsin-court-of-appeals-allows-911-dispatch-as-reverse-caller-id-for-police]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/wisconsin-court-of-appeals-allows-911-dispatch-as-reverse-caller-id-for-police#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Wed, 11 Nov 2026 19:03:29 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Alexandria Staubach]]></category><category><![CDATA[Wisconsin Court of Appeals]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/wisconsin-court-of-appeals-allows-911-dispatch-as-reverse-caller-id-for-police</guid><description><![CDATA[       By Alexandria Staubach&nbsp;Addressing a narrow and novel legal question, Wisconsin Court of Appeals District IV last week held that a law enforcement officer did not conduct a Fourth Amendment search by triggering a cell phone&rsquo;s external emergency SOS button to obtain its phone number.&nbsp;Dane County Circuit Court Judge Payal Khandhar had found that the officer&rsquo;s use of a defendant&rsquo;s phone to learn its phone number indeed constituted a search, and an unconstitutional  [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.wjiinc.org/uploads/6/1/2/9/61290857/wcoa-seal_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><font color="#2a2a2a"><font size="2">By Alexandria Staubach</font><br />&nbsp;<br />Addressing a narrow and novel legal question, Wisconsin Court of Appeals District IV last week held that a law enforcement officer did not conduct a Fourth Amendment search by triggering a cell phone&rsquo;s external emergency SOS button to obtain its phone number.<br />&nbsp;<br />Dane County Circuit Court Judge Payal Khandhar had found that the officer&rsquo;s use of a defendant&rsquo;s phone to learn its phone number indeed constituted a search, and an unconstitutional one.<br />&nbsp;<br />The Court of Appeals disagreed. Judge Jennifer E. Nashold <a href="https://www.wicourts.gov/ca/opinion/DisplayDocument.pdf?content=pdf&amp;seqNo=1201281">wrote for the three-judge panel</a>, which included Presiding Judge Rachel A. Graham and Judge Brian W. Blanchard.<br />&nbsp;<br />The Court of Appeals decision distinguished between the internal contents and data logs of a phone and use of the external, built-in emergency broadcast safety features.<br />&nbsp;&nbsp;<br />The state charged Ranken E. AhToong with attempting to flee or elude an officer and obstructing an officer. Allegations included that Deputy Trent Schafer observed a vehicle with a single illuminated headlight swerve and pass him at a high rate of speed. Schafer pursued the truck until its driver abandoned the vehicle and ran for the woods.<br />&nbsp;<br />An audiovisual recording from Schafer&rsquo;s patrol car showed a black rectangular object fall from the truck as the unidentified suspect fled.<br />&nbsp;<br />To identify the owner of the phone, Schafer pressed the external emergency SOS button on the side of the device. The action automatically initiated a call to a 911 dispatcher. Schafer asked the 911 dispatcher for the incoming phone number associated with the call.<br />&nbsp;<br />Coupling that phone number with law enforcement&rsquo;s &ldquo;Spillman system&rdquo; and social media, investigators were able to link the device to AhToong, leading to his arrest a few days later. The Spillman system contains information like driver&rsquo;s license numbers, photos, and booking photos.<br />&#8203;<br />AhToong moved to suppress the phone number and all evidence derived from it. He argued that manipulating the physical buttons on his phone to extract information without a warrant constituted an unconstitutional search under the Fourth Amendment.<br />&nbsp;<br />Khandhar agreed, ruling that individuals have a reasonable expectation of privacy in their cell phone and its number when the information is not otherwise apparent to police. The state then appealed.<br />&nbsp;<br />The Court of Appeals rejected the trial court&rsquo;s reasoning on two bases. First, the appeals court distinguished the deputy&rsquo;s conduct from landmark digital privacy cases that deal with the reasonable expectation of privacy.<br />&nbsp;<br />In the U.S. Supreme Court&rsquo;s <em>Riley v. California</em>, for instance, the state opened a flip phone, saw a photograph of a woman and baby, pressed one button on the phone to access its call log, and another to determine the phone number associated with &ldquo;my house.&rdquo; The federal Supreme Court said that &ldquo;(m)odern cell phones are not just another technological convenience. With all they contain and all they may reveal, they hold for many Americans the privacies of life,&rdquo; and held the warrantless search unconstitutional.<br />&nbsp;<br />&ldquo;No statement in <em>Riley</em>,&rdquo; wrote Nashold, &ldquo;suggests that its holding &hellip; applies to a cell phone&rsquo;s phone number, much less that pressing the phone&rsquo;s SOS button and calling 911 to obtain the number, without accessing the digital information it contains, constitutes a search.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />The Court of Appeals did not address the fact that an ordinary civilian cannot get a 911 dispatcher to tell them what number they are calling from, despite discussing other privacy cases that have delt with technology only available to law enforcement.<br />&nbsp;<br />Second, the Court of Appeals reasoned that, by design, an emergency SOS button bypasses user locks to intentionally broadcast information outward to emergency dispatchers. Because the phone number was transmitted through the standard emergency broadcast rather than extracted from the phone&rsquo;s local storage, AhToong did not retain a reasonable expectation of privacy in the deputy&rsquo;s outgoing call, Nashold wrote.<br />&nbsp;<br />By reversing the suppression order, the Court of Appeals clears the way for the state to use the phone number and resulting evidence at a trial on remand.&nbsp;<br />&nbsp;<br />However, the panel noted that whether the conduct constituted a Fourth Amendment search was a novel question in Wisconsin. Thus, the case may make it to the Wisconsin Supreme Court if AhToong seeks higher-court review.<br />&nbsp;<br />The Wisconsin Court of Appeals panel had few prior cases on which to form its opinion. However, the court discussed two jurisdictions that recently addressed the issue.<br />&nbsp;<br />A pair of nonbinding slip opinions from the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals (which includes Wisconsin) found on similar facts that &ldquo;any and all affirmative manipulations of a cell phone constitute a search.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />But Wisconsin Court of Appeals panel was not persuaded by the Seventh Circuit&rsquo;s reasoning. According to Nashold, the <em>Riley </em>court, &ldquo;specifically described certain manipulations of a cell phone that do not require a warrant, at least in the context of an arrest.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />Instead, the Wisconsin appellate court was persuaded by and adopted reasoning of the Georgia Court of Appeals, which found &ldquo;a person lacks a legitimate expectation of privacy in identifying information such as name, address, or telephone number, that is used to facilitate the routing of communications by methods such as physical mail, email, landline telephone, or cellular telephone.&rdquo;&nbsp;</font></div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA['The people's justice': Wisconsin honors and remembers Shirley Abrahamson]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/the-peoples-justice-wisconsin-honors-and-remembers-shirley-abrahamson]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/the-peoples-justice-wisconsin-honors-and-remembers-shirley-abrahamson#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Mon, 09 Nov 2026 18:01:45 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Wisconsin legal history]]></category><category><![CDATA[Wisconsin Supreme Court]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/the-peoples-justice-wisconsin-honors-and-remembers-shirley-abrahamson</guid><description><![CDATA[By Erik ReinthalerWJI InternShirley Abrahamson probably would have said people had talked about her long enough; her son, Daniel, told a crowd in the State Capitol rotunda on Friday that his mother was one of the least self-regarding people he knew. She would have wanted everyone to get back to work.But on Friday, Nov. 6, about 200 people gathered to talk about her anyway, in a ceremony to dedicate a marble bust of Wisconsin&rsquo;s first woman Supreme Court justice. They came with stories&mdash [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="paragraph"><font color="#2a2a2a"><font size="2">By Erik Reinthaler<br />WJI Intern</font><br /><br />Shirley Abrahamson probably would have said people had talked about her long enough; her son, Daniel, told a crowd in the State Capitol rotunda on Friday that his mother was one of the least self-regarding people he knew. She would have wanted everyone to get back to work.<br /><br />But on Friday, Nov. 6, about 200 people gathered to talk about her anyway, in a ceremony to dedicate a marble bust of Wisconsin&rsquo;s first woman Supreme Court justice. They came with stories&mdash;some moving, some hilarious&mdash;about a woman who was larger than life, both on and off the bench.<br /><br />Abrahamson joined the court in 1976 and served for 43 years, including 19 as chief justice. Former Gov. Jim Doyle called her one of Wisconsin&rsquo;s greatest public citizens. He also had a fitting name for her: &ldquo;the people&rsquo;s justice.&rdquo;</font></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0px;margin-right:0px;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.wjiinc.org/uploads/6/1/2/9/61290857/published/abrahamson-bust-photo.jpg?1794247725" alt="Picture" style="width:318;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%">The new marble bust of former Chief Justice Shirley Abrahamson in the Wisconsin State Capitol. Photograph by Erik Reinthaler.</div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><font color="#2a2a2a"><strong>A long way from &ldquo;unfit for female character&rdquo;<br /></strong><br />The new bust stands near the Supreme Court hearing room, alongside the marble likenesses of men who came before her. One is former Chief Justice Edward G. Ryan. In 1875, Ryan denied Lavinia Goodell permission to practice before the court, declaring law &ldquo;unfit for female character.&rdquo; Just over a century later, Abrahamson became the first woman to serve on the same court.<br />&#8203;<br />In a fitting bit of irony, Abrahamson&rsquo;s bust is slightly larger than Ryan&rsquo;s. Given his views on women in the law, it seems Abrahamson got the last laugh.<br /><br />Chief Justice Jill Karofsky, the afternoon&rsquo;s emcee, pointed out how much had changed. Six of Wisconsin&rsquo;s seven Supreme Court justices are now women. Karofsky credited Abrahamson and other trailblazers for making that possible. She also joked that Abrahamson never let a slight height disadvantage get in her way and, in keeping the ceremony moving, asked everyone to proceed in an orderly fashion, just as Abrahamson would have wanted.<br /><br />The dedication marked the first time a woman has been honored with a bust in the Supreme Court&rsquo;s space&mdash;a welcome change in a place where history has long been carved mostly in men&rsquo;s faces.</font><br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0px;margin-right:0px;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.wjiinc.org/uploads/6/1/2/9/61290857/published/abrahamson-dedication-bust-crowd.jpg?1794247651" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%">Guests gathered in the Capitol rotunda for the Nov. 6 dedication ceremony. Photograph by Erik Reinthaler.</div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><font color="#2a2a2a"><strong><br />&#8203;The way she made people feel</strong><br /><br />Doyle remembered Abrahamson as someone who knew people and genuinely liked them. He recalled a time she offered to bring chicken soup to his sick mother. Most people would picture a pot of homemade soup. Shirley arrived with a can of Campbell&rsquo;s chicken noodle soup. She had promised chicken soup, after all. She had not promised to make it. Doyle said her gift for connecting with people was central to her success, including her four statewide election victories.<br /><br />Former American Bar Association President Michelle Behnke recalled meeting Abrahamson when Behnke was a pregnant third-year law student assigned to escort the justice at a ceremony. She did not expect a conversation she would still be talking about decades later.<br /><br />Abrahamson turned to her and said, &ldquo;Don&rsquo;t let anyone tell you that you can&rsquo;t be a great lawyer and a great mom.&rdquo; Behnke said she was dumbfounded. &ldquo;A Wisconsin Supreme Court justice saw me,&rdquo; she recalled. And when a justice of that court tells you something like that, she joked, &ldquo;you don&rsquo;t file a motion for reconsideration.&rdquo;<br /><br />Amanda White Eagle spoke about another part of Abrahamson's legacy: her commitment to Wisconsin's Native communities and her respect for tribal sovereignty.<br /><br />White Eagle also shared a personal memory of Abrahamson officiating her wedding at the Madison Children's Museum. She recalled Abrahamson's warmth and approachability, including her reaction to seeing a predominantly Native gathering at the ceremony.<br /><br />That same respect carried into Abrahamson's work on the bench. White Eagle described a justice who recognized tribal courts as coequal institutions, rather than inferior to the state courts. Abrahamson encouraged cooperation between the two judicial systems, emphasizing comity, mutual respect and tribal sovereignty.<br /><br />Abrahamson also believed courts should be accessible to everyone. Programs she championed, including Court with Class and Justice on Wheels, brought students and community members into contact with the Supreme Court and took the court beyond Madison.</font></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0px;margin-right:0px;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.wjiinc.org/uploads/6/1/2/9/61290857/published/abrahamson-white-eagle-cropped-2.jpg?1794248464" alt="Picture" style="width:349;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%">Amanda White Eagle spoke about Abrahamson&rsquo;s commitment to tribal sovereignty and state-tribal judicial cooperation. Photograph by Erik Reinthaler </div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><br /><font color="#2a2a2a"><strong>&#8203;The Shirley her friends knew</strong><br /><br />Former Chief Justice Ann Walsh Bradley called Abrahamson the &ldquo;conscience of the Wisconsin Supreme Court.&rdquo; She recalled Ruth Bader Ginsburg&rsquo;s extraordinary admiration for her. Then Bradley turned to the Shirley she knew away from the bench, the one who loved farmers markets, never learned to ride a bicycle, and could be unexpectedly competitive.<br /><br />The two women, Bradley recalled, came from &ldquo;different worlds, miles and years apart.&rdquo; They had different backgrounds and did not always see things alike. But they respected those differences. &ldquo;We played well together,&rdquo; Bradley said. As it turned out, sometimes that was a dangerous invitation.<br /><br />Bradley grew up playing pool. She was quick to admit she was by no means a great player, but she knew her way around a table well enough to challenge her friend. What she did not know was that Abrahamson had learned to play pool in law school.<br />&#8203;<br />Bradley found that out the hard way. Shirley, it turned out, was a pool shark.<br /><br />Bradley told the story with good humor, recalling her own agony of defeat. It was a welcome reminder that the woman who could out-argue almost anyone on the bench could apparently wield a pool cue pretty well, too.</font></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0px;margin-right:0px;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.wjiinc.org/uploads/6/1/2/9/61290857/abrahamson-awb_orig.jpg" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%">Former Chief Justice Ann Walsh Bradley remembered Abrahamson&rsquo;s legal brilliance, their friendship, and Abrahamson&rsquo;s playful side. Photograph by Erik Reinthaler.</div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><br /><font color="#2a2a2a">&#8203;Abrahamson wrote 535 majority opinions and 493 dissents during her years on the court. Karofsky called the dissents &ldquo;love letters to the future.&rdquo; Turning to Daniel, she said, &ldquo;I think you were your mom&rsquo;s why.&rdquo; Abrahamson wanted the world to be better for him, for her grandson Moses, and for everyone who came after them. Even when she did not have the votes, she kept writing. A dissent, for Abrahamson, was never the end of the argument.<br /><br />Daniel Abrahamson thanked the people who made the sculpture possible, including stoneworkers at Quarra Stone in Sun Prairie and sculptor Martin Foot, artistic director of Quarra Italia in Pietrasanta, Tuscany. He described the rounds of drafting, editing, and reworking that went into the finished piece. That sounded about right for a justice who was never shy about revising a draft&mdash;or asking someone else to revise theirs.<br /><br />The ceremony included a poetry reading, adding a more personal touch to an afternoon filled with stories, laughter, and fond memories of Abrahamson.<br /><br />WJI previously profiled Abrahamson in an&nbsp;<a href="https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/shirley-abrahamson-mentor-ceiling-breaker-and-justice-who-sought-justice-for-all">Unsung Heroes article</a>, looking at the doors she opened for women in law and her efforts to bring the courts closer to the people they serve. The new bust gives visitors to the Wisconsin State Capitol a chance to encounter that history even if they never saw her on the bench.<br /><br />Abrahamson spent much of her life making sure other people had a place in the law. On Friday, Wisconsin made a lasting place for her.</font><br /></div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Court of Appeals orders do-over for sentence tainted by "read-in" charge]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/court-of-appeals-orders-do-over-for-sentence-tainted-by-read-in-charge]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/court-of-appeals-orders-do-over-for-sentence-tainted-by-read-in-charge#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Thu, 05 Nov 2026 17:00:00 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Alexandria Staubach]]></category><category><![CDATA[In the courts]]></category><category><![CDATA[Wisconsin Court of Appeals]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/court-of-appeals-orders-do-over-for-sentence-tainted-by-read-in-charge</guid><description><![CDATA[&#8203;By Alexandria Staubach&nbsp;A recent Court of Appeals decision underscores the importance of ensuring defendants receive every benefit promised in a plea deal and of defense attorneys remaining vigilant to ensure that agreement breaches are appropriately addressed.&nbsp;The decision involves the difference between a charge dismissed outright as part of a plea agreement and a charge dismissed but then &ldquo;read in&rdquo; for purposes of sentencing.&nbsp;In Lemar C. Newell, Jr.&rsquo;s ca [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="paragraph">&#8203;<font size="2" style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">By Alexandria Staubach</font><br /><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">&nbsp;</span><br /><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">A recent Court of Appeals decision underscores the importance of ensuring defendants receive every benefit promised in a plea deal and of defense attorneys remaining vigilant to ensure that agreement breaches are appropriately addressed.</span><br /><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">&nbsp;</span><br /><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">The </span><a href="https://www.wicourts.gov/ca/opinion/DisplayDocument.pdf?content=pdf&amp;seqNo=1194022">decision</a><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)"> involves the difference between a charge dismissed outright as part of a plea agreement and a charge dismissed but then &ldquo;read in&rdquo; for purposes of sentencing.</span><br /><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">&nbsp;</span><br /><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">In Lemar C. Newell, Jr.&rsquo;s case, at the plea hearing the prosecutor told Milwaukee County Circuit Court Judge Ellen Brostrom that pursuant to the plea agreement on one count, the second charged count should be dismissed outright instead of being dismissed and read in. But, at sentencing, the prosecutor and court read in the dismissed charge, without objection by Newell&rsquo;s counsel.</span><br /><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">&nbsp;</span><br /><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">District 1 of the Court of Appeals found that the difference resulted in a breach of the plea agreement by the state, and counsel&rsquo;s failure to object constituted ineffective assistance of counsel.</span></div>  <span class='imgPusher' style='float:left;height:0px'></span><span style='display: table;width:auto;position:relative;float:left;max-width:100%;;clear:left;margin-top:0px;*margin-top:0px'><a><img src="https://www.wjiinc.org/uploads/6/1/2/9/61290857/published/pedro-colon-1.jpg?1793835445" style="margin-top: 5px; margin-bottom: 10px; margin-left: 0px; margin-right: 10px; border-width:1px;padding:3px; max-width:100%" alt="Picture" class="galleryImageBorder wsite-image" /></a><span style="display: table-caption; caption-side: bottom; font-size: 90%; margin-top: -10px; margin-bottom: 10px; text-align: center;" class="wsite-caption">Col&oacute;n</span></span> <div class="paragraph" style="display:block;"><font color="#2a2a2a">Presiding Judge Pedro Col&oacute;n wrote for the three-judge panel, which included Chief Judge M. Joseph Donald and Judge Sara Geenen.<br />&nbsp;<br />The Court of Appeals identified distinctions between charges that are read in for sentencing purposes and those that are dismissed outright. Read-in charges are acknowledged as true, subject to restitution, and cannot be prosecuted separately in the future, Col&oacute;n wrote. Charges dismissed outright may be considered in sentencing but they are not a basis for restitution, and whether they can be prosecuted in the future depends on the terms of the plea agreement and due process considerations, wrote Col&oacute;n.</font><br /><font color="#2a2a2a">&nbsp;<br />As explained by the appeals court, a read-in charge can expose a defendant to a higher sentence.<br />&nbsp;<br />Newell had been charged with first-degree reckless homicide and first-degree recklessly endangering safety, both with the use of a dangerous weapon.<br />&nbsp;<br />Per the Court of Appeal&rsquo;s opinion, the charges stemmed from a gas station altercation. Newell was seen on camera arguing with a store clerk and customers before departing the store then returning and discharging a firearm into the station. One customer died from multiple gunshot wounds.<br />&nbsp;<br />Newell signed a plea agreement with the state by which he would be convicted of the reckless homicide charge. The recklessly endangering safety charge and dangerous weapon enhancements would be dismissed but read in at sentencing.<br />&nbsp;<br />At the plea hearing, though, the judge asked for clarification on whether the recklessly endangering safety count and dangerous use of weapon enhancement were to be dismissed outright or read in.</font><font color="#2a2a2a"><br /><br />On the record, the prosecutor responded, &ldquo;I&rsquo;ve never understood the difference,&rdquo; and said that the charge should be &ldquo;dismissed outright.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />The court responded, &ldquo;Oh. No. That does make a difference.&rdquo; But based on what she heard, she dismissed the charge outright.<br />&nbsp;<br />At the subsequent sentencing hearing, the state recommended 25 to 28 years of initial confinement and 12 years of extended supervision, noting that the reckless endangerment charge was dismissed.<br />&nbsp;<br />The judge again asked, &ldquo;Dismissed and read in?&rdquo; The prosecutor responded, &ldquo;I don&rsquo;t recall off-hand.&rdquo; The parties then reviewed and relied on the written agreement without objection from Newell&rsquo;s attorney, and the dismissed charge was read in.<br />&nbsp;<br />The court imposed a 28-year sentence, the high end of the prosecutor&rsquo;s recommendation.<br />&nbsp;<br />On appeal, Newell argued that the state committed a material and substantial breach of the plea agreement and that his attorney&rsquo;s failure to object constituted infective assistance of counsel.<br />&nbsp;<br />The state countered that its breach was not material and substantial and that, even if it was, Newell could not demonstrate prejudice by his counsel&rsquo;s failure to object.<br />&nbsp;<br />The Court of Appeals concluded that the state&rsquo;s breach was indeed material and that Newell was prejudiced by his counsel&rsquo;s failure to object.<br />&nbsp;<br />&ldquo;The read-in procedure is not, strictly speaking, an aspect of the plea bargaining,&rdquo; wrote Col&oacute;n, citing a Wisconsin Supreme Court case. &ldquo;Rather, it is a sentencing mechanism that is often used in plea negotiations.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />The court found that despite the written agreement stating that the recklessly endangering safety charge was to be dismissed but read in, the plea deal placed on the record controlled, and what occurred at sentencing differed. That difference, the court wrote, resulted in the state failing to present the negotiated sentencing recommendation and breaching the plea agreement.<br />&nbsp;<br />By telling the court to read in the second count, the state &ldquo;exposed Newell to a higher likelihood of more punishment than what was initially bargained for,&rdquo; wrote Col&oacute;n.<br />&nbsp;<br />Wisconsin law presumes prejudice in this situation. &ldquo;When the State materially and substantially breaches the plea agreement it always results in prejudice to the defendant,&rdquo; Col&oacute;n wrote.<br />&nbsp;<br />&ldquo;Counsel&rsquo;s failure to object to the State&rsquo;s breach flew in the face of the informed strategic choice made by Newell&rdquo; and &ldquo;constituted a breakdown in the adversarial system,&rdquo; the court said.<br />&nbsp;<br />The panel remanded the case to circuit court for a new sentencing hearing.</font></div> <hr style="width:100%;clear:both;visibility:hidden;"></hr>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Prosecutor-heavy Supreme Court appears inclined to overlook serious defense counsel error]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/prosecutor-heavy-supreme-court-appears-inclined-to-overlook-serious-defense-counsel-error]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/prosecutor-heavy-supreme-court-appears-inclined-to-overlook-serious-defense-counsel-error#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Wed, 04 Nov 2026 17:58:11 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Alexandria Staubach]]></category><category><![CDATA[In the courts]]></category><category><![CDATA[Wisconsin Supreme Court]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/prosecutor-heavy-supreme-court-appears-inclined-to-overlook-serious-defense-counsel-error</guid><description><![CDATA[    Entrance to the Wisconsin Supreme Court at the State Capitol in Madison in December 2024. Photograph by Alexandria Staubach.   By Alexandria Staubach&nbsp;During oral arguments in October, the prosecutor-heavy Wisconsin Supreme Court appeared quite skeptical of an intermediate appeals court decision overturning a guilty verdict for ineffective assistance of counsel.&nbsp;Last year, the Wisconsin Court of Appeals reversed a Columbia County man&rsquo;s conviction for both delivery of heroin an [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0px;margin-right:0px;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.wjiinc.org/uploads/6/1/2/9/61290857/published/img-2896.jpeg?1793822468" alt="Picture" style="width:432;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%">Entrance to the Wisconsin Supreme Court at the State Capitol in Madison in December 2024. Photograph by Alexandria Staubach.</div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><font color="#2a2a2a"><font size="2">By Alexandria Staubach</font><br />&nbsp;<br />During oral arguments in October, the prosecutor-heavy Wisconsin Supreme Court appeared quite skeptical of an intermediate appeals court decision overturning a guilty verdict for ineffective assistance of counsel.<br />&nbsp;<br />Last year, the Wisconsin Court of Appeals reversed a Columbia County man&rsquo;s conviction for both delivery of heroin and first-degree reckless homicide by delivery of heroin after the man&rsquo;s attorney, the prosecutor, and the judge all failed to appreciate and timely instruct a jury that the two charges were in fact a single offense with a lesser included charge.<br />&nbsp;<br />The appeal was based on a 1984 U.S. Supreme Court case, <em>Strickland v. Washington</em>, which established the constitutional standard for ineffective assistance of counsel.<br />&nbsp;<br />Under the <em>Strickland </em>standard, defendant Samuel Osornio needed to establish that his trial attorney performed in an objectively unreasonable manner and that there was a reasonable probability that the outcome would have been different but for the deficient attorney performance.<br />&nbsp;<br />Judge Brian Blanchard wrote for the three-judge appeals court panel, which included Presiding Judge JoAnne Kloppenburg and then-appeals-court Judge Chris Taylor.<br />&nbsp;<br />The case involves what is known as &ldquo;multiplicity.&rdquo; It occurs when the same elements are required to prove multiple charges that stem from the same facts. A defendant cannot be sentenced on two such charges (that&rsquo;s double jeopardy) even if found guilty of both offenses.<br />&nbsp;<br />In Osornio&rsquo;s case, the delivery charge and the reckless homicide charge are not distinct under the law. Instead, the reckless homicide offense takes the delivery charge one step further, adding an element about whether the delivery caused the consumer&rsquo;s death.<br />&nbsp;<br />The presence of a lesser offense would typically change the jury instructions given to a jury, especially if the jury finds itself in gridlock, which was the case here.<br /><br />Osornio&rsquo;s jury was not initially told that the delivery charge was a lesser-included offense of the reckless homicide offense.<br />&nbsp;<br />Four hours into deliberation, the jury informed the trial court that it was deadlocked as to the reckless homicide offense, but that it had consensus as to the delivery charge.<br />&nbsp;<br />When a jury is deadlocked, it typically receives a special instruction, and, if a lesser included offense is present, the court messaging could include that if after every reasonable effort the jury cannot reach a verdict on the more serious offense, it could proceed to the resolve the lesser-included offense.<br />&nbsp;<br />Failing to appreciate the multiplicity issue, the court instructed the jury to continue its deliberations, treating the two charges as separate offenses that jury needed to decide.<br />&nbsp;<br />A while later, the jury asked to see an additional piece of evidence. By this time, the attorneys and court realized their error. The judge gave a modified lesser-included instruction and returned the jury to its deliberations.<br />&nbsp;<br />An hour later the jury returned a guilty verdict on both charges.<br />&nbsp;<br />Blanchard wrote that there was &ldquo;a substantial, not merely a conceivable, likelihood that a jury that was properly instructed from the start would have reached a more favorable result for Osornio.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />The appeals court decision was based largely on the defense attorney&rsquo;s failure to appreciate that the delivery charge was a lesser included offense of the homicide charge. The court found both deficient performance by the attorney and prejudice to Osornio.<br />&nbsp;<br />According to the Court of Appeals written decision, &ldquo;the missed potential benefit to Osornio should have been obvious from the time the case was charged through to the time of trial.&rdquo;&nbsp;<br />&nbsp;<br />The Supreme Court justices&rsquo; questions and comments during oral arguments suggested that they will not agree. Oral arguments focused heavily on the instructions the jury did receive and whether different instructions would have changed the outcome.<br />&nbsp;<br />Taylor, who did not participate in the proceeding, and Justice Brian Hagedorn are the only sitting Supreme Court justices who do not have some background as criminal prosecutors.<br />&nbsp;<br />The parties agreed that the charges arose from the same conduct of delivering heroin and the elements in the reckless homicide offense include the essential elements for the delivery of heroin offense.<br />&nbsp;<br />But Wisconsin Department of Justice attorney Michael J. Conway argued to the Supreme Court that Osornio could not prove he was &ldquo;deprived of anything to which he was constitutionally entitled,&rdquo; and that the Court of Appeals impermissibly produced its conclusion by speculating about what a jury would have done if it had received a lesser-included instruction sooner.<br />&nbsp;<br />Conway called the scenario &ldquo;unknowable,&rdquo; and wholly speculative.<br />&nbsp;<br />The devil was in the details as the court considered the underlying facts, with Justice Susan Crawford at one point stating, &ldquo;I feel like we&rsquo;re angels dancing on a pinhead.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />Osornio&rsquo;s attorney, Michael George Soukup, argued that the situation could have caused confusion for the jury.<br />&nbsp;<br />The jury in Osornio&rsquo;s trial deliberated for roughly eight hours, protracted for a brief two-day trial.<br />&nbsp;<br />&ldquo;We don&rsquo;t know what the jury would have done if the jury was properly instructed,&rdquo; he argued. &ldquo;The (ineffective assistance of counsel) standard requires a reasonable probability, not certainty.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />&ldquo;I think you have some members of this court that question whether this was deficient performance,&rdquo; said Justice Janet Protasiewicz.<br />&nbsp;<br />Other justices seemed to agree. Crawford said that Osornio&rsquo;s position &ldquo;seems to require that the jury did not discharge its duties.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />&ldquo;I am struggling to see where the prejudice is,&rdquo; said Crawford. &ldquo;Don&rsquo;t we have to assume that the jury found there was guilt beyond a reasonable doubt because that&rsquo;s the verdict they returned?&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />Soukup tried to argue that the instruction failed to guide the jury through the greater and lesser offenses, they should only reach one verdict, and they were not convicting Osornio of two separate crimes.<br />&nbsp;<br />&ldquo;We don&rsquo;t know what the jury may have done if they were properly instructed from the beginning.&rdquo; he said.<br />&nbsp;<br />But the bench seemed skeptical.<br />&nbsp;<br />While the current Supreme Court is often labeled as &ldquo;liberal&rdquo; on a host of social issues, that moniker does not necessarily extend to criminal cases.<br />&nbsp;<br />Research by Supreme Court statistician and Marquette history professor Alan Ball indicates that while the current court is indeed liberal regarding several issues, it is less liberal than courts over the last 30 years when it comes to criminal defendants. According to Ball&rsquo;s research, the present court <a href="https://scowstats.com/2026/07/13/how-liberal-is-the-supreme-court/">is the least receptive to criminal defendants&rsquo; arguments</a> of any version of the court since 1995, siding with criminal defendants only 20% of the time. In comparison, the court found in favor of defendants 31% of the time from 1995-2004 and 28% of the time from 2004-2008.&nbsp;<br /><br />WJI's discussion of the Court of Appeals decision can be found <a href="https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/counsel-and-judges-failure-to-appreciate-multiplicity-issue-means-new-trial-for-columbia-county-defendant" target="_blank">here</a>.</font></div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Evers' judges: Michael C. Schindhelm]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/evers-judges-michael-c-schindhelm]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/evers-judges-michael-c-schindhelm#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Thu, 29 Oct 2026 09:18:57 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Evers' judges]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/evers-judges-michael-c-schindhelm</guid><description><![CDATA[&#8203;&#8203;"Evers' judges" is our effort to present information about Gov. Tony Evers' appointees to the bench. The information is taken from the appointees' own judgeship applications.&nbsp;Italics indicate direct quotes from the application.&#8203; Typos, including punctuation errors, come from the original application even though we have not inserted &ldquo;(sic)&rdquo; after each one. WJI has left them as is.&nbsp;   Name: Michael C. Schindhelm&#8203;Appointed to: Waukesha County Circuit  [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="paragraph">&#8203;<span style="color:rgb(129, 129, 129)">&#8203;</span><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">"Evers' judges" is our effort to present information about Gov. Tony Evers' appointees to the bench. The information is taken from the appointees' own judgeship applications.</span><br /><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">&nbsp;</span><br /><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">Italics indicate direct quotes from the application.&#8203; Typos, including punctuation errors, come from the original application even though we have not inserted &ldquo;(sic)&rdquo; after each one. WJI has left them as is.&nbsp;</span></div>  <span class='imgPusher' style='float:left;height:0px'></span><span style='display: table;width:324px;position:relative;float:left;max-width:100%;;clear:left;margin-top:0px;*margin-top:0px'><a><img src="https://www.wjiinc.org/uploads/6/1/2/9/61290857/published/schindhelm-mike.png?1793265631" style="margin-top: 5px; margin-bottom: 10px; margin-left: 0px; margin-right: 10px; border-width:1px;padding:3px; max-width:100%" alt="Picture" class="galleryImageBorder wsite-image" /></a><span style="display: table-caption; caption-side: bottom; font-size: 90%; margin-top: -10px; margin-bottom: 10px; text-align: center;" class="wsite-caption"></span></span> <div class="paragraph" style="display:block;"><font color="#2a2a2a"><strong>Name:</strong> Michael C. Schindhelm<br />&#8203;<br /><strong>Appointed to:</strong> Waukesha County Circuit Court<br /><br /><strong>Appointment date:</strong> July 3, 2026, to term ending July 31, 2027<br /><br /><strong>Education:</strong><br /><strong>Law School &ndash;</strong> St. John&rsquo;s University, Queens, New York<br /><strong>Undergraduate &ndash;</strong> The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio<br /><strong>High School &ndash;</strong> Mukwonago High, Mukwonago, Wisconsin<br />&nbsp;<br /><strong>Recent legal employment:</strong><br /><strong>September 2023-present &ndash;</strong> Assistant U.S. attorney, United States Department of Justice, EDWI, Milwaukee, Wisconsin<br /><strong>July 2012-September 2023 &ndash;</strong> Assistant district attorney, Milwaukee County District Attorney&rsquo;s Office, Milwaukee, Wisconsin<br /><strong>June 2011-July 2012 &ndash;</strong> Assistant district attorney, Fond du Lac County District Attorney&rsquo;s Office, Fond du Lac, Wisconsin<br /><strong>April 2007-April 2011 &ndash;</strong> Assistant district attorney, Queens County District Attorney&rsquo;s Office, Kew Gardens, New York<br />&nbsp;<br /><strong>Bar and administrative memberships:</strong><br />New York (resigned from bar in 2011 after moving to Wisconsin)<br />Illinois (retired from bar in 2011 after moving to Wisconsin)<br />State Bar of Wisconsin<br />&nbsp;<br /><strong>General Character of practice:</strong><br /><em>I am a career prosecutor&mdash;working to protect victims and prosecute crimes for 19 years.&nbsp; I have done that work in New York City, in Fond du Lac, and in Milwaukee. Recently I have transitioned from being an Assistant District Attorney, representing the State of Wisconsin to becoming an Assistant United States Attorney, representing the United States.</em><br />&nbsp;<br /><strong>Describe typical clients:</strong><br /><em>As a prosecutor, the client is always the people you represent, so my client has been the People of the State of Wisconsin and now the United States. However, within that work I've generally focused on crimes of violence and particularly violence that targets the most vulnerable. My years as a Domestic Violence prosecutor formed my approach to the law, and I took lessons I learned and applied them as a Sensitive Crimes Prosecutor, as a Gun Crimes Prosecutor and finally prosecuting homicides.</em><br />&nbsp;<br /><em>This specialization manifests two ways, First, I often view cases through that domestic abuse lens&mdash;I know what it takes for a victim to disclose, or what it means when a defendant grew up in a DV household. Second, I developed an expertise in cases where victims wouldn't testify. I became fluent in Crawford and hearsay exceptions and I used this skill many times, including for example to charge Nicholas Howell (2023CF001158), with the stalking and homicide of his ex-girlfriend, despite many inadequacies in the prior law enforcement responses to her attempts to get help.</em><br />&nbsp;<br /><strong>Number of cases tried to verdict:</strong> 122 including 28 homicides<br />&nbsp;<br /><strong>List up to three significant trials, appeals, or other legal matters in which you participated as a judge or lawyer in the past seven years:</strong><br /><em>It is difficult to pick the three most significant cases of my career. When I was brand new in the Milwaukee Homicide Unit I tried Wisconsin v. Matthew Neumann, (2019CF000204), the prosecution of a Franklin business owner for the murder of two of his employees. The trial was conducted by the Honorable Jeffrey Wagner, the most experienced homicide judge in the State. My opponent was Attorney Michael J. Steinle, who I believe to be the gold standard of the Milwaukee defense bar. I took over this case after it had been charged and tried it as the sole representative of the State of Wisconsin.&nbsp; Neumann killed his two employees and burned their bodies&mdash;one was burned so badly even DNA could not identify the remains. That fact, along with the lack of direct witnesses made it a challenging case. However, Neumann was found guilty on all counts</em><em> and sentenced to 72 years of initial confinement and 28 years of extended supervision. </em><br />&nbsp;<br /><em>The worst homicide I tried was the road rage murder of an 11-year-old girl.&nbsp; I worked this case from the day of the murder, helping detectives build the case against Antonius Trotter (2021CF004565). I charged the case and tried it, again as the sole representative of the State of Wisconsin. My opponent was Attorney Kerri Cleghorn, and the case was tried before The Honorable Laura Crivello, both of whom I also have a great deal of respect for. This prosecution was extremely difficult because it featured two witnesses who were in the car with Trotter when he fired the shots&mdash;both had to be located and arrested to get them on the witness stand.&nbsp; It was also difficult from a vicarious trauma standpoint&mdash;I will never forget watching the body camera of the paramedics trying to save the child and loading her onto the ambulance. In the end Trotter was convicted on all counts and sentenced to 60 years of initial confinement and 35 years of extended supervision. The victim was a talented artist and after the sentencing her family gave me a self-portrait she had drawn. It is on the wall of my office and reminds me every day what the stakes are in the criminal justice system.</em><br />&nbsp;<br /><em>Every case is significant, and it was difficult to pick a third. I wanted to write about Milwaukee trials like Xavier Wade (2019CF4995), a drug dealer who killed a disadvantaged woman over a stolen car; or about Ted Stevens (2016CF004636 &amp; 2017CF002053) who stalked and raped his long-term girlfriend. I also first-chaired a recent completed murder for hire case (23-CR-77) here in the Eastern District of Wisconsin which resulted in convictions for both defendants on all counts. They await sentencing but face statutory minimums of life in prison.</em><br />&nbsp;<br /><em>However, the job of a prosecutor isn't to secure convictions&mdash;it is to seek justice. A very few times in my career I've either charged or inherited a case I later came to believe was not provable. One such case was 2019CF001405. I took this case over after it was charged. The fact pattern was as follows&mdash;two juvenile males were hanging out in an apartment hallway for hours, likely selling drugs. The victim, a resident of the building, confronted them as she left for work one morning. They argued, and one of the two shot her. The identity of the two could be proven&mdash;however I became convinced it was not possible to prove which had shot her. Because of the nature of the incident (a spontaneous argument) there was no evidence that the non-shooter was legally a party to the charged homicide. In the end I became convinced that I could not prove the defendant was the shooter and I moved to dismiss the case.</em><br />&nbsp;<br /><em>This decision was extremely difficult: the homicide happened in 2007 and was first charged in 2019, meaning the victim's family had waited over a decade for what they hoped would be justice. I had to tell them that it was not coming yet&mdash;that if we tried the case on the evidence available we might win but that would not be justice.</em><br />&nbsp;<br /><strong>Experience in adversary proceedings before administrative bodies:</strong><br /><em>My work has been almost exclusively in the courts.</em><br />&nbsp;<br /><strong>Describe your non-litigation experience (e.g., arbitration, mediation).</strong><br /><em>My career has focused on litigation.</em><br />&nbsp;<br /><strong>Position or involvement in judicial, non-partisan, or partisan political campaign, committee, or organization:</strong><br /><em>I volunteered for Mike Thurston's 2024 campaign for Waukesha County District Attorney. This involved mostly walking with him in local parades and handing out campaign literature. I also wrote an endorsement for him in the Waukesha Freeman.</em><br />&nbsp;<br /><strong>Previous runs for public office:</strong> NA<br />&nbsp;<br /><strong>All judicial or non-partisan candidates endorsed in the last ten years:</strong><br />Mike Thurston, Waukesha District Attorney, 2024<br />Janet Protasiewicz, Wisconsin Supreme Court Justice, 2022<br />&nbsp;<br /><strong>Professional or civic and charitable organizations:</strong><br />Lake Country Phoenix Swim Team, board member, approximately 08/24-present<br />Wisconsin Association of State Prosecutors, member, approximately 04/12-09/23<br />&nbsp;<br /><strong>Significant pro bono legal work or volunteer service:</strong><br /><em>Unfortunately my career as a prosecutor has not significant time for pro bono legal work. I do volunteer for organizations related to my kids' sports-- I have been an assistant coach on my son's travel baseball team for the last five years; and I have served on the board of my daughter's swim team for the last two years.</em><br />&nbsp;<br /><strong>Quotes:</strong><br />&nbsp;<br /><strong>Why I want to become a judge:</strong><br /><em>I think I have shown a dedication to the people of Wisconsin and to the rule of law throughout my career as a prosecutor. I believe that experience, balanced by my empathetic approach to the justice system makes me ready to take on a different role. I was born at Waukesha Memorial hospital, and my parents still live in the house in Mukwonago where I grew up. I returned to Waukesha 10 years ago&mdash;my wife and I are homeowners in Delafield and we&rsquo;re raising our two kids in local public schools. These deep Waukesha roots give me both an understanding of the community and a stake in what happens here.</em><br />&nbsp;<br /><strong>Describe which case in the past 25 years by the Wisconsin Supreme Court or the U.S. Supreme Court you believe had a significant positive or negative impact on the people of Wisconsin.</strong><br /><em>As I mentioned above&mdash;the single most important legal decision in the arc of my career has been </em>Crawford v. Washington<em>, 541 U.S. 36 (2004). I was an intern in the Queens District Attorney&rsquo;s Office Domestic Violence Unit when the decision came down, and I vividly remember the instantaneous dismay over the decision. Over time I&rsquo;ve come to appreciate </em>Crawford&rsquo;s <em>necessity&mdash;the struck down practice in Washington state of having domestic abuse victims sign affidavits at the police station as a substitute for trial testimony certainly was overly ambitious and violates the Confrontation Clause. But I can&rsquo;t help but wonder if a humbler and more narrow decision would have limited all the damage done by </em>Crawford<em> and avoided the years it took to clarify the admissibility of traditional hearsay exceptions like excited utterances.</em><br />&nbsp;<br /><em>I&rsquo;m proud to have had an impact on this clarification in several cases:</em><br />&nbsp;<br /><em>In </em>State v. Zamzow<em> (Fond du Lac case #2016CT000145) the defendant was charged with an OWI 3rd Offense after being stopped by a police officer. At the suppression hearing, he objected on Confrontation grounds to the admission of the audio portions of the police body camera video, which I presented with a creative foundation because the officer had tragically been killed in the line of duty prior to the motion hearing. The argument centered on the defense belief that Confrontation rights applied at the suppression hearing and their claim that prior case law stating they did not had been overturned by </em>Crawford<em>. Eventually, the Court of Appeals agreed with my argument and the trial court that the Confrontation Clause was not implicated at this motion hearing and denied Zamzow&rsquo;s appeal. </em>State v. Zamzow<em>, 366 Wis.2d 562.</em><br />&nbsp;<br /><em>In </em>State v. Mercado<em>, (Milwaukee case #2016CF003679), the defendant sexually assaulted several of his neighbor&rsquo;s children. The trial court admitted the video-taped forensic interview of the children and the defendant was convicted on all counts. The Appellate Court disagreed with that admission and overturned the conviction. The Wisconsin Supreme Court reversed that decision in full, holding that the residual hearsay exception of Wis. Stats. <strong>&sect;</strong>908.03(24) covered the video-taped statement of 4-year-old [redacted] the youngest of those children. </em>State v. Mercado<em>, 395 Wis.2d 296.</em><br />&nbsp;<br /><em>I also tried several felony domestic abuse cases (each before now Supreme Court Justice Rebecca Dallet) which resulted in unpublished court of appeals rulings upholding the admission of 911 calls over Hearsay and </em>Crawford <em>objections in each case. (</em>State v. Hunter<em>, 365 Wis.2d 348, </em>State v. Moore<em>, 378 Wis.2d 740, and </em>State v. Jackson<em>, 372 Wis.2d 458).</em><br />&nbsp;<br /><strong>Two or three judges whom I admire and why:</strong><br /><em>The Honorable Jeffrey A. Wagner is a recently retired Milwaukee County Judge. He was notable for his longevity, his work ethic&mdash;always helping other branches by taking spins, and for his start time (famously 15 minutes before any other branch). However, what struck me most about Judge Wagner is how much he cared about the victims of cases. He can be extremely gruff and impatient&mdash;but I have seen him stop everything in a trial and do everything in his power to make a child victim feel comfortable in his courtroom.</em><br />&nbsp;<br /><em>The Honorable Joseph A. Zayas was a misdemeanor judge when I started my career in Queens, New York. I tried both my first conviction and my last New York City case in front of him. That first case was an OWI 1st conviction after a bench trial. The last was a home invasion burglary by a mandatory persistent felon whom Judge Zayas sentenced to 15 years prison after the conviction. However, what I&rsquo;ll always remember about Judge Zayas was his blending of a fearsome intellect and mastery of the law with a relaxed, friendly and approachable demeanor. If you knew your case and tried to do the right thing (on either side of the courtroom), Judge Zayas&rsquo; court was a welcoming place. I googled him just now and was not surprised to learn that he had risen, first to be the Administrative Judge for Supreme Court in Queens County, then to the New York Appellate Courts and now to be Chief Administrative Judge for the entire New York State Judiciary. </em><br />&nbsp;<br /><em>I didn&rsquo;t want to pick a single judge for a third example. I have appeared in front of a large number of extraordinary jurists in my career, and I would list the following as some of judges who had a memorable and positive influence on the way I view the law: Judge Fernando M. Camacho (Queens, NY); Judge Robert C. McGann (Queens, NY); Judge Gary R. Sharpe (Fond du Lac, WI); and Milwaukee Judges: Daniel L. Konkol, Rebecca F. Dallet, M. Joseph Donald, Michelle A. Havas, Mark A. Sanders, Joseph Wall, Frederick C. Rosa, Janet C. Protasiewicz and Laura A. Crivello.</em><br />&nbsp;<br /><strong>The proper role of a judge:</strong><br /><em>The role of a judge is to find the proper balance between two naturally competing ideas: 1. The law should be certain, knowable and predictable; and 2. Every situation is different, and that variety leads to unpredictability. The first idea is a simple one: the rule of law mandates that the law should be both written in advance and applied consistently to everyone. It would be unfair if judges changed the law or applied it differently to different people. This goal of predictable uniformity is why the legislature writes the laws and also why judges rely on precedent to guide</em><em> their decisions. This idea is critically important and the baseline requirement for any good judge. However, the second idea is just as important&mdash; people are individuals and need to be treated that way. The deeper you look at what happened and why in a case (and judges should look deeply), the more variables there are. And sometimes&mdash;those variations can be both important and not predicted by the law. In those situations, a judge has to find their own way&mdash;relying on statutes and precedent certainly but also fitting that law to the unique facts of the case. The tension between these two ideas is at the heart of the role of a judge.</em></font><br /></div> <hr style="width:100%;clear:both;visibility:hidden;"></hr>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[WJI presentations on the constitutional amendment ballot questions]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/wji-presentations-on-the-constitutional-amendment-ballot-questions]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/wji-presentations-on-the-constitutional-amendment-ballot-questions#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Tue, 27 Oct 2026 12:30:00 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Constitutional  Amendments]]></category><category><![CDATA[Constitutional amendments 2026]]></category><category><![CDATA[Margo Kirchner]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/wji-presentations-on-the-constitutional-amendment-ballot-questions</guid><description><![CDATA[When it comes to getting up to speed on the constitutional amendment ballot questions, do you like presentations and PowerPoints more than reading blog posts? If so, here are two talks by WJI's executive director, Margo Kirchner, about the constitutional amendments on the Nov. 3 ballot.The shorter talk for the Women's Fund of Greater Milwaukee discusses how to analyze constitutional amendments whenever you see them. The First Unitarian Society of Milwaukee talk includes that same topic plus deta [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="paragraph"><font color="#2a2a2a"><font size="4">When it comes to getting up to speed on the constitutional amendment ballot questions, do you like presentations and PowerPoints more than reading blog posts? If so, here are two talks by WJI's executive director,</font> <font size="4">Margo Kirchner, about the constitutional amendments on the Nov. 3 ballot.<br /><br />The shorter talk for the Women's Fund of Greater Milwaukee discusses how to analyze constitutional amendments whenever you see them. <br /><br />The First Unitarian Society of Milwaukee talk includes that same topic plus detail on the three particular constitutional amendment ballot questions voters face this election season.<br /><br />BE SURE TO VOTE ON OR BEFORE NOV. 3! And when you fill out your ballot, be sure to keep going all the way down toward the end to find the amendment questions.</font></font></div>  <div class="wsite-youtube" style="margin-bottom:10px;margin-top:10px;"><div class="wsite-youtube-wrapper wsite-youtube-size-auto wsite-youtube-align-center"> <div class="wsite-youtube-container">  <iframe src="//www.youtube.com/embed/hYmjqACuxE8?wmode=opaque" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe> </div> </div></div>  <div class="wsite-youtube" style="margin-bottom:10px;margin-top:10px;"><div class="wsite-youtube-wrapper wsite-youtube-size-auto wsite-youtube-align-center"> <div class="wsite-youtube-container">  <iframe src="//www.youtube.com/embed/oEYJLEiAO0Q?wmode=opaque" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe> </div> </div></div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Licensed to assist: A proposal to allow limited legal advocate certification]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/licensed-to-assist-a-proposal-to-allow-limited-legal-advocate-certification]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/licensed-to-assist-a-proposal-to-allow-limited-legal-advocate-certification#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Mon, 26 Oct 2026 23:46:37 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Access to justice]]></category><category><![CDATA[Alexandria Staubach]]></category><category><![CDATA[In the courts]]></category><category><![CDATA[Wisconsin Supreme Court]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/licensed-to-assist-a-proposal-to-allow-limited-legal-advocate-certification</guid><description><![CDATA[By Alexandria StaubachThe Wisconsin Access to Justice Commission and the Quarles &amp; Brady law firm have formally proposed a Supreme Court rule to create a limited-license, nonlawyer practitioner program to address the need for legal representation in many parts of the state.&nbsp;The petitioners hope the rule will permit &ldquo;legal advocates who are certified, trained, and supervised&rdquo; to advise and advocate for clients in &ldquo;limited, appropriate contexts.&rdquo;&nbsp;&ldquo;In Wis [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="paragraph"><font color="#2a2a2a"><font size="2">By Alexandria Staubach</font><br /><br />The Wisconsin Access to Justice Commission and the Quarles &amp; Brady law firm have formally proposed a Supreme Court rule to create a limited-license, nonlawyer practitioner program to address the need for legal representation in many parts of the state.<br />&nbsp;<br />The petitioners hope the rule will permit &ldquo;legal advocates who are certified, trained, and supervised&rdquo; to advise and advocate for clients in &ldquo;limited, appropriate contexts.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />&ldquo;In Wisconsin, low-income households face more difficulty finding civil legal aid because of the attorney shortage,&rdquo; they wrote, pointing out that state funding lags when compared to other states. Legal service provider organizations as a result are overly reliant on federal grants, private donations, and volunteers. That structure is particularly precarious as <a href="https://grantwitness.org/updates/tracking-177-billion-in-disrupted-federal-grants-with-the-lost-funds-project">billions in long-standing federal grants have dried up</a> under the current administration.&nbsp;<br />&nbsp;<br />A November 2025&nbsp;<a href="https://www.wicourts.gov/publications/reports/docs/arrcreport25.pdf">attorney retention report</a>&nbsp;created for the Wisconsin Supreme Court found that 73% of Wisconsin lawyers reside in just three Wisconsin judicial districts, which cover just 45% of the state&rsquo;s population. That distribution of lawyers means that many portions of the state just do not have enough to meet the demand for their services.<br />&nbsp;<br />Compounding the disparity, many of the communities where attorney populations have declined the most over the last five years are the same communities with the largest share of population growth during the same period. La Crosse is one example.<br />&nbsp;<br />Urban communities with the greatest share of attorneys, such as Milwaukee, have seen declines in attorney numbers as well, though less exaggerated.<br />&nbsp;<br />The report included recommendations to address the growing problem. One idea was for a limited-license practitioner program to help fill the gap.<br />&nbsp;<br />The petitioners&rsquo; proposed rule to permit nonlawyer legal advocates is broad by design in some ways, loosely based on restrictions imposed on law students practicing under a licensed attorney. In other ways, the proposed program is restrictive, with significant limitations on what types of matters legal advocates would be allowed to handle.<br />&nbsp;<br />The petitioners believe they have crafted a rule that will increase access to justice while protecting the public with adequate monitoring. They hope to fill the gap in the market for legal services for those who would ordinarily go without counsel.<br />&nbsp;<br />The proposed rule would require advocates to have a bachelor&rsquo;s or associate degree, or a high school diploma plus five years of relevant experience. In addition, advocates would have to pass a background check; complete substantive and ethical training on an ongoing basis, and be found to have good moral character by the certifying entity. The certifying entity would be a law firm where a supervising attorney works.<br />&nbsp;<br />Advocates would be prohibited from providing limited and supervised representation in any criminal matter, generally any civil trial where the rules of evidence apply, any divorce in which marital assets exceed $100,000, civil disputes that exceed the monetary limitations of small claims court (except eviction matters), cases regarding termination of parental rights or children or juveniles in need of protection; matters before the Supreme Court or Court of Appeals, or matters involving mental health or guardianship.<br />&nbsp;<br />Who will benefit? The petitioners say &ldquo;the busiest and most neglected dockets in Wisconsin&rdquo;&mdash;both rural and urban&mdash;for &ldquo;matters that are too small for many attorneys to take but significant for the client involved.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />The advocates will &ldquo;serve as a bridge between proceeding <em>pro se</em> and engaging counsel,&rdquo; according to the petition.<br />&nbsp;<br />The petitioners say that the legal advocate program will not take work away from Wisconsin attorneys because the legal advocates must work under the supervision of licensed attorneys. Instead, petitioners say, the legal advocates, &ldquo;will enhance Wisconsin attorneys&rsquo; ability to reach areas not currently receiving adequate legal representation.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />The proposed rule would create a standing committee on the legal advocate program, with members appointed by the Supreme Court in collaboration with the Wisconsin Access to Justice Commission.<br />&nbsp;<br />The standing committee would administer and supervise the program and recommend any changes in scope or permissions if required.<br />&nbsp;<br />According to supporting documents, the model is supported by empirical research from states like Alaska, with its Justice Worker Program. Minnesota and the District of Columbia have also adopted similar limited-legal license practitioner programs. Other states are exploring similar rule changes.<br />&nbsp;<br />The Supreme Court has called for public comments on the petition to be filed by Dec. 31, 2026.<br />&nbsp;<br />A full record of the petition can be found <a href="https://www.wicourts.gov/scrules/pending/2604.htm">here</a>.&nbsp;</font></div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Book review: In superb book, journalist Tony Messenger condemns court fines and justice system fees]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/book-review-in-superb-book-journalist-tony-messenger-condemns-court-fines-and-justice-system-fees]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/book-review-in-superb-book-journalist-tony-messenger-condemns-court-fines-and-justice-system-fees#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Wed, 21 Oct 2026 16:30:09 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Gretchen Schuldt]]></category><category><![CDATA[Justice Reform]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/book-review-in-superb-book-journalist-tony-messenger-condemns-court-fines-and-justice-system-fees</guid><description><![CDATA[Schuldt If you're reading this blog, you are very likely concerned about justice in Wisconsin, the country, and across the world. But you're probably also pretty busy. How do you choose which books about the justice system to read during your limited free time?In a series of posts, Wisconsin Justice Initiative founder and former executive director Gretchen Schuldt helps you out. An avid reader, she returns to the blog with book reviews so you can decide what's of interest to you and what's worth [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<span class='imgPusher' style='float:left;height:0px'></span><span style='display: table;width:133px;position:relative;float:left;max-width:100%;;clear:left;margin-top:0px;*margin-top:0px'><a><img src="https://www.wjiinc.org/uploads/6/1/2/9/61290857/published/gretchen-6.jpeg?1792600387" style="margin-top: 10px; margin-bottom: 10px; margin-left: 0px; margin-right: 10px; border-width:0; max-width:100%" alt="Picture" class="galleryImageBorder wsite-image" /></a><span style="display: table-caption; caption-side: bottom; font-size: 90%; margin-top: -10px; margin-bottom: 10px; text-align: center;" class="wsite-caption">Schuldt</span></span> <div class="paragraph" style="display:block;"><em style="color:rgb(129, 129, 129)"><font color="#2a2a2a">If you're reading this blog, you are very likely concerned about justice in Wisconsin, the country, and across the world. But you're probably also pretty busy. How do you choose which books about the justice system to read during your limited free time?<br /><br />In a series of posts, Wisconsin Justice Initiative founder and former executive director Gretchen Schuldt helps you out. An avid reader, she returns to the blog with book reviews so you can decide what's of interest to you and what's worth your time.</font></em></div> <hr style="width:100%;clear:both;visibility:hidden;"></hr>  <div class="paragraph"><font color="#2a2a2a"><span><span style="font-weight:700">Profit and Punishment: How America Criminalizes the Poor in the Name of Justice</span><span>, by Tony Messenger. St. Martin&rsquo;s Press,&nbsp;</span></span>235 pages,&nbsp;<span><span>2021.</span></span><br /><br /><span><span>Journalist Tony Messenger&rsquo;s excellent, maddening book shows just how illogical, counter-productive, and harmful even the small-crime end of our courts system is.&nbsp;</span></span><br /><br /><span><span>His work is a useful primer in the real workings of the law and a clear condemnation of the backdoor taxes and harmful nonfinancial costs levied by legislators, prosecutors, and judges on people, especially poor people, accused of those low-level offenses.</span></span><br /><br /><span><span>For years, in some cases, Messenger writes, defendants are caught in a cycle of jail and court appearances stemming from their inability to pay fines, fees, and &ldquo;pay-to-stay&rdquo; jail charges. In others instances, an inability to pay forfeitures and fines leads to driver&rsquo;s license suspensions, which means there is a good chance the person involved won&rsquo;t have the transportation needed to get to work to earn the money to pay the fine.</span></span><br /><br /><span><span>Wisconsin is all in on that latter punishment. Roughly half of driver&rsquo;s license suspensions are because of unpaid traffic fines or forfeitures. The state also allows jails to charge people held in custody for their stays; Messenger said at least 23 counties do just that. And municipal courts, where offenses are considered civil violations and not criminal offenses, are empowered by state law to jail defendants who are unable to pay their forfeitures.&nbsp;</span></span><br /><br /><span><span>Messenger, a columnist for the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, focuses on stories of real people caught in Missouri&rsquo;s version of the court and fines cycle and approach that makes the system&rsquo;s gross flaws conspicuous and immediate in a way that a less personal approach cannot do. He writes mostly about his own state of Missouri, but the jail-related poverty penalties imposed through courts and sheriff&rsquo;s departments exist all over the country.</span></span><br /><br /><span><span>One of the Missouri people Messenger writes about, Brooke Bergen, an addict, who was arrested for stealing an $8 tube of lipstick. She got probation for her crime. A judge later sent her to jail for 10 days for failing to answer a phone call for a random drug screen, a probation violation. The jail billed her for her stay. She was later jailed again, this time for 14 days, when she failed a drug test administered by a private firm with a questionable reputation for the accuracy of its results.</span></span><br /><br /><span><span>Bergen&rsquo;s jail bill, despite a few payments, rose to $943.50.&nbsp;</span></span><br /><br /><span><span>The judge finally sent Bergen to jail for a year when another probation violation allegation was lodged against her. As a result, her husband took custody of their child and Bergen was ordered to pay $277 per month in child support. On top of that, her jail board bill was now over $15,000. She had to show up in court every month to make a payment or explain why she could not.&nbsp;</span></span><br /><br /><span><span>&ldquo;They put all this on you and you can&rsquo;t get out,&rdquo; Bergen said. &ldquo;They made it impossible for me to get on with my life.&rdquo;</span></span><br /><br /><span><span>The Missouri Supreme Court ruled in 2019 that courts could not jail people for nonpayment of jail board fees, but that decision had less to do with justice than with a technicality: the legislature failed to specify pay-to-stay charges as court costs, so courts lacked the authority to help counties collect them. Delinquencies are now collected via civil measures (as they are in Wisconsin). Messenger suggests that not all judges embraced the spirit of the high court decision and still demand that defendants appear frequently in court to discuss their payments. If they miss their appearances they can be jailed for </span><span>that</span><span> sin and end up with even more pay-to-stay debt.</span><span>&nbsp;&nbsp; &nbsp;</span><span>&nbsp;&nbsp; &nbsp;</span><span>&nbsp;&nbsp; &nbsp;</span><span>&nbsp;&nbsp; &nbsp;</span><span>&nbsp;&nbsp; &nbsp;</span><span>&nbsp;&nbsp; &nbsp;</span><span>&nbsp;&nbsp; &nbsp;</span><span>&nbsp;&nbsp; &nbsp;</span><span>&nbsp;&nbsp; &nbsp;</span><span>&nbsp;&nbsp; &nbsp;</span><span>&nbsp;&nbsp; &nbsp;</span></span><br /><br /><span><span>The poverty penalties can start well before conviction, Messenger points out. Anyone who can&rsquo;t afford a $500 bail, for example, will sit in jail awaiting trial and may well be expected to pay for the pleasure.&nbsp;&nbsp;</span></span><br /><br /><span><span>Does anyone benefit from such systems? Yes, according to Messenger. Counties or sheriff&rsquo;s departments collecting the board fees benefit monetarily. Prosecutors and judges benefit because people stuck in jail are more likely to plead guilty just to get the ordeal over with, obviating the need for trial and all its time-consuming demands and processes.</span></span><br /><br /><span><span>This unjust system exists because cash-strapped local governments need or want the money and don&rsquo;t want to raise taxes on the general population, Messenger argues.</span></span><br /><br /><span><span>Elected judges go along with it because they don&rsquo;t want to anger powerful constituencies, including law enforcement and their buddies in local and state governments, where decisions are made on things like, oh, court budgets.</span></span><br /><br /><span><span>In addition, said Michael Wolff, a retired law school dean, &ldquo;Some locally elected judges are just mean peckerheads who are perhaps representative of their constituents.&rdquo;</span></span>&#8203;</font></div>  <div><div class="wsite-multicol"><div class="wsite-multicol-table-wrap" style="margin:0 -15px;"> 	<table class="wsite-multicol-table"> 		<tbody class="wsite-multicol-tbody"> 			<tr class="wsite-multicol-tr"> 				<td class="wsite-multicol-col" style="width:31.77874186551%; padding:0 15px;"> 					 						  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.wjiinc.org/uploads/6/1/2/9/61290857/published/messenger-book-jacket.jpg?1792600626" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>   					 				</td>				<td class="wsite-multicol-col" style="width:68.22125813449%; padding:0 15px;"> 					 						  <div class="paragraph"><em><font color="#2a2a2a">Tony Messenger is a journalist for the St. Louis Post-Dispatch. His work focuses on criminal justice reform, poverty, and race,&nbsp;<span>documenting how poor Americans are convicted of minor crimes and then saddled with significant fines and fees. He won a Pulitzer Prize in 2019 for his series of columns on debtors' prison practices in Missouri.<br /><br />In October 2019, WJI brought Messenger to Milwaukee to headline a talk titled "</span>From Ferguson to the Finish Line:&nbsp; A Path Forward on Criminal Justice Reform."</font></em></div>   					 				</td>			</tr> 		</tbody> 	</table> </div></div></div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Opinion: Anti-equity amendment is for a post-racial state we haven't built yet]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/opinion-anti-equity-amendment-is-for-a-post-racial-state-we-havent-built-yet]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/opinion-anti-equity-amendment-is-for-a-post-racial-state-we-havent-built-yet#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Mon, 19 Oct 2026 20:53:15 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Alexandria Staubach]]></category><category><![CDATA[Constitutional  Amendments]]></category><category><![CDATA[Constitutional amendments 2026]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/opinion-anti-equity-amendment-is-for-a-post-racial-state-we-havent-built-yet</guid><description><![CDATA[        By Alexandria Staubach&nbsp;Wisconsin&rsquo;s Legislature asks voters to pass a constitutional amendment that in essence refutes the legitimacy of the 1964 Civil Rights Act.&nbsp;The proposed amendment, question 3 on the Nov. 3 ballot, follows a national movement that seeks to reframe civil rights laws as discriminatory against white Americans. It passed through the Legislature along party lines.&nbsp;A lead sponsor, Rep. Dave Murphy (R-Hortonville), says the amendment would prohibit gov [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.wjiinc.org/uploads/6/1/2/9/61290857/editor/blog-post-opinion-take-3.png?1792444640" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <span class='imgPusher' style='float:left;height:0px'></span><span style='display: table;width:auto;position:relative;float:left;max-width:100%;;clear:left;margin-top:0px;*margin-top:0px'><a><img src="https://www.wjiinc.org/uploads/6/1/2/9/61290857/staubach-headshot-cropped-2_orig.jpg" style="margin-top: 5px; margin-bottom: 10px; margin-left: 0px; margin-right: 10px; border-width:1px;padding:3px; max-width:100%" alt="Picture" class="galleryImageBorder wsite-image" /></a><span style="display: table-caption; caption-side: bottom; font-size: 90%; margin-top: -10px; margin-bottom: 10px; text-align: center;" class="wsite-caption"></span></span> <div class="paragraph" style="display:block;"><font color="#2a2a2a"><font size="2">By Alexandria Staubach</font><br />&nbsp;<br />Wisconsin&rsquo;s Legislature asks voters to pass a constitutional amendment that in essence refutes the legitimacy of the 1964 Civil Rights Act.<br />&nbsp;<br />The <a href="https://docs.legis.wisconsin.gov/2025/related/enrolled/ajr102">proposed amendment</a>, question 3 on the Nov. 3 ballot, follows a national movement that seeks to <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2025/sep/28/supreme-court-louisiana-v-callais">reframe civil rights laws as discriminatory</a> against white Americans. It passed through the Legislature along party lines.<br />&nbsp;<br />A lead sponsor, Rep. Dave Murphy (R-Hortonville), says the amendment would prohibit governmental entities from &ldquo;discriminating against or granting preferential treatment to anyone based on race, sex, color, ethnicity, or national origin in public employment, education, contracting, or administration.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />The proposal is one of three constitutional amendments that will appear on November ballots, but this one, question 3, is uniquely situated to ask voters to ignore reality.<br />&nbsp;<br />According to Murphy in his written support of the measure, the bill &ldquo;Restores MERIT,&rdquo; &ldquo;Restores FAIRNESS,&rdquo; &ldquo;Restores EQUALITY,&rdquo; and will provide, &ldquo;equal <strong>opportunity</strong> for all, not forced equal outcomes (&ldquo;equity&rdquo;) that ignore ability.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />At this juncture in U.S. history, it is worth remembering that since the abolition of slavery in 1865, racial discrimination has, in theory, been illegal in the United States by the guarantee of equal protection of the law.<br />&nbsp;<br />Only the last of the Civil War Amendments, the 15th Amendment, though, mention races discrimination as explicitly unconstitutional. It proclaims, &ldquo;the right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or any state on account of race, color, or pervious condition of servitude.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />The Wisconsin Constitution, like the U.S. Constitution, also already guarantees equal protection of the law regardless of race. It says, &ldquo;all people are born equally free and independent, and have certain rights&rdquo; and &ldquo;to secure these rights, governments are instituted, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />What then is the point of a constitutional amendment prohibiting discrimination? What is Murphy promising to &ldquo;restore&rdquo; with this amendment?<br />&nbsp;<br />Prior to the 1964 Civil Rights Act (99 years after we ended slavery), states, including Wisconsin, persisted in an end run of the U.S. Constitution. From redlining to voter literacy tests, policies perpetuated inequality among the races, claiming to ensure &ldquo;separate but equal&rdquo; protection of the law.<br />&nbsp;<br />Recognizing the states&rsquo; failure to realize the promise of the Constitution, the Civil Rights Act sought to enforce equal protection against the states where a pattern or practice of discrimination persisted.<br />&nbsp;<br />But lawmakers also recognized that systemic racism was so deeply enmeshed in U.S. society that states would need to be sued into compliance. That is why the 1964 Civil Rights Act permits the attorney general to pursue injunctive relief against those who fail to integrate or otherwise persist in discriminatory action.<br />&nbsp;<br />Only through double-think can reasonable and informed people believe identity-based programs aimed at leveling the playing field in a country that persisted in state-sanctioned discrimination for more than two centuries is the <em>real</em> discrimination threatening equality.<br />&nbsp;<br />To be clear, we never collectively woke up and decided racism was wrong&mdash; that some people weren&rsquo;t inferior based solely on the immutable characteristic of race.<br />&nbsp;<br />Just a generation ago, <a href="https://segregationinamerica.eji.org/report/massive-resistance.html">millions of white Americans organized against desegregation</a> in a movement called &ldquo;Massive Resistance,&rdquo; following the battle to desegregate schools after <em>Brown vs. Board of Education</em>.<br />&nbsp;<br />And still, as recently as the 2020-2021 school year, &ldquo;over 33 percent of students &hellip; attended a school where more than three-quarters of the students were of a single-ethnicity&mdash;showing that de facto segregation still exists,&rdquo; according to the Supreme Court Historical Society.<br />&nbsp;<br />Proponents of the amendment, including Sen. Steve Nass (R-Whitewater), argue that &ldquo;past discrimination, however wrong, cannot be corrected with more discrimination.&rdquo; They support the idea that ameliorative measures required by the social damage wrought from 250 years of institutionalized racism are somehow pernicious and the real driver of discrimination.<br />&nbsp;<br />&ldquo;Old wounds cannot be healed by inflicting new ones,&rdquo; Nass wrote in support of the bill.<br />&nbsp;<br />But the amendment ignores an unfortunate reality. Wisconsin remains among the most the racially segregated states in the U.S. and is among the states who have made the least strides toward racial integration, edging out only the District of Columbia in overall ranking in a <a href="https://wallethub.com/edu/states-with-the-most-and-least-racial-progress/18428">recent study</a>.<br />&nbsp;<br />The most recent data shows Wisconsin is among the five states with the least progress in racial integration over time, failing to close racial gaps between Black residents and white residents in median annual income, labor force participation, standardized test scores, and voter turnout.<br />&nbsp;<br />Despite these facts, Murphy says the bill is a &ldquo;proven model&rdquo; and is based on Michigan&rsquo;s 2006 constitutional amendment, which banned affirmative action before the U.S. Supreme Court did so formally in <a href="https://www.oyez.org/cases/2022/21-707"><em>Students for Fair Admissions v. University of Noth Carolina</em></a>.<br />&nbsp;<br />But Michigan is neck and neck with Wisconsin in its failure to achieve an integrated population or make strides toward disparate outcomes, ranking 47 to Wisconsin&rsquo;s 50 for least racial integration and 42 compared to Wisconsin&rsquo;s 46 for racial integration progress over time.<br />&nbsp;<br />So, a similar amendment did not &ldquo;RESTORE equality&rdquo; in Michigan.<br />&nbsp;<br />It&rsquo;s not surprising because equality never existed.<br />&nbsp;<br />Passage of the question 3 amendment would signal to minorities and women that we&rsquo;re ready to wash our hands of the plight wrought by years of inequity, that this is as level that playing field will get, that we&rsquo;re content with the status quo.<br />&nbsp;<br />It feels worth mentioning that none of the proposed amendment&rsquo;s sponsors hails from a racially diverse city within the state. Whitewater, where Nass is from, is 83.2% white, according to recent U.S. Census data.<br />&nbsp;<br />Instead, the proposed amendment targets municipalities living with and still struggling to reconcile the knock-on effects of segregation.<br />&nbsp;<br />Among the targets is Milwaukee County&rsquo;s Racial Equity Budget Tool. In its written support of the proposed amendment, Wisconsin Institute for Law &amp; Liberty cites the budget tool as a discriminatory practice the amendment would ban.<br />&nbsp;<br />The budget tool, which the county describes as a &ldquo;structured equity lens,&rdquo; so that government departments can &ldquo;critically assess the impacts of budget decisions on communities of color,&rdquo; is a county response to 2019 statistics showing that a white Milwaukeean lives an average 14 years longer than a Black Milwaukeean, and the Black infant mortality rate is about three times that of white infants.<br />&nbsp;<br />In support of the amendment, Murphy said &ldquo;this isn&rsquo;t a new policy,&rdquo; and &ldquo;it&rsquo;s a return to Wisconsin&rsquo;s core values.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />Voters need ask what those &ldquo;core values&rdquo; are and whether we really want to enshrine our commitment to these disparities in the state&rsquo;s constitution.<br />&nbsp;<br />We need to ask whether we want to be a community that sits on its hands, prohibiting the occasional, sometimes lifesaving, hand up in the name of the delusional idea that we&rsquo;re living in a post-racial America.&nbsp;</font></div> <hr style="width:100%;clear:both;visibility:hidden;"></hr>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[November ballot question 3: Prohibiting targeted government benefits for minority individuals and women]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/november-ballot-question-3-prohibiting-targeted-government-benefits-for-minority-individuals-and-women]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/november-ballot-question-3-prohibiting-targeted-government-benefits-for-minority-individuals-and-women#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Mon, 12 Oct 2026 20:36:19 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Alexandria Staubach]]></category><category><![CDATA[Constitutional  Amendments]]></category><category><![CDATA[Constitutional amendments 2026]]></category><category><![CDATA[Margo Kirchner]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/november-ballot-question-3-prohibiting-targeted-government-benefits-for-minority-individuals-and-women</guid><description><![CDATA[Wisconsin voters will encounter three constitutional amendment referendum questions on the Nov. 3 ballot. In a series of posts, Wisconsin Justice Initiative will help you understand constitutional amendment referendum questions generally, and the Nov. 3 election questions specifically. This is part five in the series. Find prior posts here.   By Alexandria Staubach and Margo KirchnerBallot question 3 is the most destructive proposed constitutional amendment voters will face on Nov. 3; it's a reg [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="paragraph"><em style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">Wisconsin voters will encounter three constitutional amendment referendum questions on the Nov. 3 ballot. In a series of posts, Wisconsin Justice Initiative will help you understand constitutional amendment referendum questions generally, and the Nov. 3 election questions specifically. This is part five in the series. Find prior posts <a href="https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/category/constitutional-amendments-2026" target="_blank">here</a></em><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">.</span></div>  <span class='imgPusher' style='float:left;height:0px'></span><span style='display: table;width:252px;position:relative;float:left;max-width:100%;;clear:left;margin-top:0px;*margin-top:0px'><a><img src="https://www.wjiinc.org/uploads/6/1/2/9/61290857/published/no-equity.png?1791840138" style="margin-top: 5px; margin-bottom: 10px; margin-left: 0px; margin-right: 10px; border-width:1px;padding:3px; max-width:100%" alt="Picture" class="galleryImageBorder wsite-image" /></a><span style="display: table-caption; caption-side: bottom; font-size: 90%; margin-top: -10px; margin-bottom: 10px; text-align: center;" class="wsite-caption"></span></span> <div class="paragraph" style="display:block;"><font color="#2a2a2a"><font size="2">By Alexandria Staubach and Margo Kirchner</font><br /><br />Ballot question 3 is the most destructive proposed constitutional amendment voters will face on Nov. 3; it's </font><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">a regressive ploy.</span><br /><font color="#2a2a2a">&nbsp;<br />The proposed amendment is anti-equity masquerading as anti-discrimination. Despite supporters' sales pitch, the amendment targets far more than higher education admissions or what we teach in schools.<br />&nbsp;<br />Voters will be asked whether the government shall be prohibited from &ldquo;discriminating against, or granting preferential treatment to, any individual or group on the basis of race, sex, color, ethnicity, or national origin.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />The amendment, though, is really about banning consideration of race, sex, color, ethnicity, or national origin when creating programs, services, opportunities, and targeted health care.&nbsp;If enacted, the question 3 constitutional amendment threatens to eliminate long-standing initiatives based on identity-conscious designations that address persistent inequalities in health care, public education, housing, government contracting, and more.</font><br /><br /><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">The amendment would apply to every level of government.</span><br /><font color="#2a2a2a">&nbsp;<br />It could enshrine in the state&rsquo;s constitution a total ban on targeted support for women and minority communities.<br />&nbsp;<br />Wisconsin Justice Initiative and Wisconsin Justice Initiative Action encourage voters to say &ldquo;NO.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />The proposed constitutional amendment appears on the ballot as &ldquo;Governmental Entity Discrimination Prohibited Referendum&mdash;QUESTION 3.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />Although the referendum question is titled to "prohibit discrimination," WJI believes a more accurate title would have been the "anti-equity amendment." Discrimination is already prohibited in laws regarding housing, employment, education, health care, and in other areas. What this amendment adds is prohibitions against &ldquo;preferential treatment.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />The ballot question asks voters: <em>&ldquo;Shall section 27 of article I of the constitution be created to prohibit governmental entities in the state from discriminating against, or granting preferential treatment to, any individual or group on the basis of race, sex, color, ethnicity, or national origin in public employment, public education, public contracting, or public administration?&rdquo;</em><br />&nbsp;<br />The actual amendment is longer than the question and is shown in the box below. The key language of the proposed amendment, though, indeed is: &ldquo;<em>A governmental entity may not discriminate against, or grant preferential treatment to, any individual or group on the basis of race, sex, color, ethnicity, or national origin in public employment, public education, public contracting, or public administration.&rdquo;</em><br />&nbsp;<br />However, there is a key carve-out, not mentioned in the question, allowing for sex-based discrimination if a &ldquo;bona fide qualification&rdquo; based on sex is &ldquo;reasonably necessary to the normal operation of public employment, public education, public contracting, or public administration.&rdquo; It is entirely unclear who would decide that sex is a bona fide qualification necessary for the job or benefit at issue and how that would be policed.<br /><br />Wisconsin Institute for Law &amp; Liberty is the only organization registered in support of the amendment, but it is putting in overtime trying to win a &ldquo;yes&rdquo; from voters.</font><br /><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">&nbsp;</span><br /><a href="https://will-law.org/vote/">Two advertisements</a><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)"> produced by WILL, featuring &ldquo;Colbey, a Wisconsin mom,&rdquo; and &ldquo;Richard, a Wisconsin parent,&rdquo; say &ldquo;every Wisconsin kid deserves an equal shot&rdquo; and &ldquo;race or gender should never give anyone an advantage or disadvantage,&rdquo; respectively.</span><br /><font color="#2a2a2a">&nbsp;<br />WILL frames the measure as a natural reaction to the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in <em>Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard</em>, which eliminated affirmative action in higher education in 2023.&nbsp;</font><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">But using the tagline </span><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">&ldquo;Discrimination is</span><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)"> Discrimination,&rdquo;</span><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)"> WILL takes the position further on its website, saying that &ldquo;governments may not use race to cure societal discrimination, systemic racism, or to advance modern-day notions of diversity and equity.&rdquo;</span><br /><font color="#2a2a2a">&nbsp;<br />The proposed amendment would affect more than simply education. Instead, ballot question 3 is a backdoor into the wholesale elimination of a host of programs that anti-DEI proponents would love to see sunset.<br />&nbsp;<br />In written testimony when the Legislature most recently considered the proposed amendment, WILL expressly pointed to the following programs it expects will be prohibited:</font><ul><li><font color="#2a2a2a">Wisconsin Supplier Diversity Program, which aims for&nbsp;5% of the state&rsquo;s supplier contracts to be awarded to minority-owned businesses.</font></li><li><font color="#2a2a2a">Wisconsin Department of Health Services grants to improve health outcomes, including for alcohol and drug abuse, currently limited to non-white and non-Asian racial groups.</font></li><li><font color="#2a2a2a">Milwaukee County&rsquo;s racial equity budget tool, which regarding the spending of county money considers the impact on various races and endeavors to racially balance outcomes.</font></li><li><font color="#2a2a2a">City of Milwaukee&rsquo;s Office of African American Affairs.</font></li></ul> <font color="#2a2a2a">&nbsp;</font><br /><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">While WILL is pitching the constitutional amendment as an education initiative, it has compiled a </span><a href="https://will-law.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/Equality-for-All-July-5-2023-v-7.pdf">list</a><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)"> of Wisconsin laws, programs, and policies that it claims are discriminatory. (The firm has also published lists of </span><a href="https://will-law.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Equality-Agenda_pdf-2.7.25.pdf">federal programs</a><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)"> and </span><a href="https://will-law.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/NEW_FINAL_WILLs-Roadmap-to-Equality-E28093-55-RB-HHS-Federal-Funding-Initiatives-Final-1.pdf">federally funded health initiatives</a><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)"> that it claims discriminate based on race.)</span><br /><br /><font color="#2a2a2a">Tasked by the 2025 Government Operations, Accountability, and Transparency Committee, Rep. Shae Sortwell (R-Two Rivers) <a href="https://legis.wisconsin.gov/assembly/02/Sortwell/sortwell-dei-report/">compiled a list</a> of every &ldquo;DEI&rdquo; initiative in the state. The exhaustive list includes everything from sensitivity training for state adoption agencies, to targeted library intern positions in communities of color, to county health equity plans.<br />&nbsp;<br />Think about the end to programs like</font><ul><li><font color="#2a2a2a">Girls in STEM.</font></li><li><font color="#2a2a2a">Encouragement&nbsp;to boost the number of male grade school teachers.</font></li><li><font color="#2a2a2a">Health programs targeting the needs of Black mothers, who face three-times the mortality rate of white mothers.</font></li><li><font color="#2a2a2a">Encouragement and support for minority individuals to make it through medical school with the goal of&nbsp;serving underprivileged communities.</font></li><li><font color="#2a2a2a">Demographic-specific mentoring programs at all levels of public education.</font></li><li><font color="#2a2a2a">Implicit bias training.</font></li></ul> <font color="#2a2a2a">&nbsp;<br />Anti-discrimination sounds like a non-partisan no-brainer, and WILL has <a href="https://will-law.org/wisconsin-voters-strongly-support-equality-amendment-lean-toward-ending-governors-excessive-partial-veto-authority/">recently claimed</a> that a &ldquo;statewide survey&rdquo; (of just 750 registered Wisconsin voters) demonstrates &ldquo;majority support across party lines.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />However, the Legislature passed the amendment exactly along party lines. Further, there is shockingly little preserved about its passage,&nbsp;compounded by WisconsinEye&rsquo;s blackout last winter.<br />&nbsp;<br />The resolution passed through the Assembly&rsquo;s Committee on Judiciary in November 2025. While the resolution received a public hearing before WisconsinEye shutdown temporarily, the event wasn&rsquo;t covered.<br />&nbsp;<br />WJI reached out to Judiciary Committee member Rep. Andrew Hysell (D-Sun Prairie). At the November 2025 hearing, Hysell, one of the few attorneys in the Legislature, warned of the many unintended consequences this amendment may have.<br />&nbsp;<br />In a recent phone call with WJI, Hysell specifically noted the proposed amendment&rsquo;s exception allowing sex discrimination when &ldquo;reasonably necessary&rdquo; and recounted his hearing testimony.<br />&nbsp;<br />&ldquo;What does 'reasonably necessary' mean?&rdquo; he asked. It&rsquo;s an important question for Hysell, who believes the language would insert discriminatory language directly into the state constitution&mdash;that the &ldquo;reasonably necessary&rdquo; phrase is intended to insert a &ldquo;bona fide occupational exception&rdquo; into the amendment.<br />&nbsp;<br />&ldquo;The idea of a bona fide qualification based on sex is from the 1960s,&rdquo; he told WJI and the Judiciary Committee. &ldquo;It&rsquo;s been used to argue in the 1970s that men shouldn&rsquo;t be flight attendants and women shouldn&rsquo;t be prison guards,&rdquo; he said.<br />&nbsp;<br />Sex discrimination issues have long been resolved by the courts, but placing the language in the state constitution, detached from the context and years of corresponding jurisprudence, &ldquo;would turn a statutory exception policed and limited by the courts into a constitutional limitation on your right to be free from sex discrimination,&rdquo; he explained.&nbsp;<br />&nbsp;<br />By the time the resolution made it to the Senate, where it received a public hearing in the Licensing, Regulatory Reform, State and Federal Affairs Committee, WisconsinEye was offline.<br />&nbsp;<br />After the hearing, Sen. Dora Drake (D-Milwaukee) said in a press release that &ldquo;Legislative Republicans had the opportunity to expand economic and educational opportunities for all Wisconsinites over a decade, yet they chose not to. Now, as many Wisconsinites are struggling more than ever, they are attempting to eliminate historically bipartisan programs and guardrails by claiming that they provide preferential treatment based on race, sex, ethnicity, or national origin.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />Drake said the authors admitted they conducted no research on the impact to these established programs. She said they&nbsp;"promote manufactured discrimination and conceal their incompetence and neglect to help all Wisconsinites.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />&ldquo;This proposed ballot measure is designed to not name specific programs or provide legislative solutions but to mislead voters and blame women and Wisconsinites of color for the struggles this body refuses to solve,&rdquo; she said in the press release.<br />&nbsp;<br />On second consideration, written testimony in support was received only from WILL, the amendment&rsquo;s authors, and two individuals. Sponsor Rep. Dave Murphy (R-Hortonville) stated in written testimony that the proposed amendment &ldquo;Restores FAIRNESS&mdash;No one gets an unfair advantage; no one is unfairly held back&rdquo; and &ldquo;Restores EQUALITY&mdash;Equal opportunity for all, not forced equal outcomes (&ldquo;equity&rdquo;) that ignore ability.&rdquo; Sen. Steve Nass (R-Whitewater) stated that &ldquo;(p)ast discrimination, however wrong, cannot be corrected with more discrimination.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />For a deeper dive, the Senate hearing materials are <a href="https://docs.legis.wisconsin.gov/misc/lc/hearing_testimony_and_materials/2025/sjr94/sjr0094_2026_01_07.pdf">here</a> and the Assembly hearing materials are <a href="https://docs.legis.wisconsin.gov/misc/lc/hearing_testimony_and_materials/2025/ajr102">here</a>.<br />&nbsp;&nbsp;<br />WJI reached out to WILL to ask what the amendment would do to enhance equality. WJI has received no response to date.<br />&nbsp;<br />After it was clear the &ldquo;anti-discrimination&rdquo; question would appear on the Nov. 3 ballot, the Wisconsin Supreme Court released its opinion in <em>Rabiebna v. Higher Educational Aids Board. </em>In that case, WILL argued a challenge under</font><span style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">&nbsp;</span><em style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">Students for Fair Admissions&nbsp;</em><font color="#2a2a2a">to small ($500-$2,000) race-based technical college scholarships.<br />&nbsp;<br />While the justices ruled the program was now unconstitutional under </font><em style="color:rgb(42, 42, 42)">Students for Fair Admissions</em><font color="#2a2a2a">, they questioned the decision they had to make. In a concurring opinion, Justice Jill Karofsky wrote, &ldquo;Why have we not learned from our past? Why are we not willing to recognize the harms this country has caused to those who are marginalized, disempowered, or disenfranchised?&rdquo;&nbsp;The answer she said, &ldquo;appears to be because we have failed to fully recognize how societal and governmental practices have long continued to enforce a preference for White Americans and to burden Black Americans and those of other disadvantaged races or backgrounds.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />WJI encourages voters to ask themselves whether they believe identity-conscious health care is in fact discriminatory, whether equality means only equal inputs (everyone gets the same) rather than equal outputs (people get what they need to similarly succeed), and whether banning support for people long subject to discrimination is something we want enshrined in Wisconsin&rsquo;s foundational document.</font></div> <hr style="width:100%;clear:both;visibility:hidden;"></hr>  <div id="557606234628701781"><div><style type="text/css">	#element-75313a65-e1ac-4e2d-ad7b-40d7fa4d876d .colored-box-content {  clear: both;  float: left;  width: 100%;  -moz-box-sizing: border-box;  -webkit-box-sizing: border-box;  -ms-box-sizing: border-box;  box-sizing: border-box;  background-color: #0f6fc6;  padding-top: 20px;  padding-bottom: 20px;  padding-left: 20px;  padding-right: 20px;  -webkit-border-top-left-radius: 0px;  -moz-border-top-left-radius: 0px;  border-top-left-radius: 0px;  -webkit-border-top-right-radius: 0px;  -moz-border-top-right-radius: 0px;  border-top-right-radius: 0px;  -webkit-border-bottom-left-radius: 0px;  -moz-border-bottom-left-radius: 0px;  border-bottom-left-radius: 0px;  -webkit-border-bottom-right-radius: 0px;  -moz-border-bottom-right-radius: 0px;  border-bottom-right-radius: 0px;}</style><div id="element-75313a65-e1ac-4e2d-ad7b-40d7fa4d876d" data-platform-element-id="848857247979793891-1.0.1" class="platform-element-contents">	<div class="colored-box">    <div class="colored-box-content">        <div style="width: auto"><div></div><div class="paragraph"><font color="#fefcfc" size="4">The proposed amendment, which is more detailed than the ballot question:<br /><br /><em>[Article I] Section 27 (1) In this section, &ldquo;governmental entity&rdquo; means the state, its political subdivisions including municipalities, the University of Wisconsin System, the Technical College System, any public college or university, any public school district, and any office, department, independent agency, board, commission, authority, institution, association, society, or other body in state or local government created or authorized to be created by the constitution or any law, including the legislature and the courts.<br /><br />(2) A governmental entity may not discriminate against, or grant preferential treatment to, any individual or group on the basis of race, sex, color, ethnicity, or national origin in public employment, public education, public contracting, or public administration.<br /><br />(3) This section does not prohibit action that must be taken to establish or maintain eligibility for any federal program, if ineligibility would result in a loss of federal funds to the governmental entity.<br /><br />(4) Nothing in this section prohibits bona fide qualifications based on sex that are reasonably necessary to the normal operation of public employment, public education, public contracting, or public administration.<br /><br />(5) If any part or parts of this section are found to be in conflict with the United States Constitution or federal law, the section shall be implemented to the maximum extent that the United States Constitution and federal law permit. Any provision of this section held invalid shall be severable from the remaining portions of this section.</em></font></div></div>    </div></div></div><div style="clear:both;"></div></div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.wjiinc.org/uploads/6/1/2/9/61290857/published/q3-ppt-slides-for-blog.jpg?1791840031" alt="Picture" style="width:672;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.wjiinc.org/uploads/6/1/2/9/61290857/published/q3-ppt-slides-for-blog-slide-2-revised.jpg?1791840035" alt="Picture" style="width:672;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>]]></content:encoded></item></channel></rss>